- This page contains affiliate links. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.
Pittsburgh (28-15-11) at NY Islanders (30-21-5)
- When: Feb 3 2026, 6:30 PM
- Where: UBS Arena, Belmont Park, NY, USA
- TV: TNT
Pittsburgh vs NY Islanders NHL Preview & Pick
Moneyline: NY Islanders -120
Spread: NY Islanders -1.5 (+220)
Total: 6.0
Islanders Trying To Look Calm While Everything Wobbles
The New York Islanders are doing that thing where they tell everyone they are fine while slowly backing into traffic. On paper, they are still in a playoff spot. In reality, they keep handing away leads like party favors.
New York enters this matchup as a slight moneyline favorite at one twenty, which feels less like confidence and more like polite optimism. They just blew another early advantage and followed it up by losing to a team they absolutely needed to beat. That is not ideal behavior when the standings are tightening and the Olympic break is lurking like a deadline reminder.
The Islanders have had moments. Mathew Barzal can still make magic happen out of nowhere, but the problem is what happens after that first goal. Defensive lapses, slow responses, and long stretches where the offense disappears have turned manageable games into long walks back to the locker room.
This team wants structure and calm. What they keep getting is chaos with a side of regret.
Penguins Living Life On The Hockey Roller Coaster
Pittsburgh is the most confusing team in the Metropolitan Division and honestly it is impressive. One week they look unstoppable. The next week they forget how to shoot the puck more than sixteen times.
The Penguins just saw a hot streak evaporate with a loss that felt ugly from start to finish. Erik Karlsson said it best when he admitted the group did not have much in the tank. That honesty might actually matter here.
Why? Because Pittsburgh has been very good after being embarrassed. When expectations drop, they tend to simplify. Fewer cute passes. More forecheck. More grind. That style travels well and it frustrates teams that already feel tense.
Despite their inconsistency, the Penguins still have veteran leadership and enough experience to steal games when things feel uncomfortable. This matchup screams uncomfortable.
Why This Smells Like An Upset
The Islanders are favored. The building will be loud. The standings say New York needs this. All of that pressure points in one direction.
Pittsburgh, meanwhile, just wants to play spoiler and hit the break without spiraling. That is a dangerous mindset for a road underdog.
The total sits at six, which feels about right. Expect a tight first period, some nervous energy, and then a couple of mistakes that flip the game late. This is not about dominance. This is about timing and nerves.
Betting Prediction
New York might control possession, but Pittsburgh feels more desperate and desperation tends to cash tickets.
The Islanders skate hard, the Penguins skate smarter, and the upset walks quietly out of Elmont with two points and a smile.
Score Prediction: Penguins 4, Islanders 3
Pick: Pittsburgh ML (+100)
Total: Over 6.0 (-112)
- NHL Odds source: Bovada Sportsbook
