- This page contains affiliate links. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.
Toronto (81-59) at NY Yankees (78-62)
- When: Sep 5 2025, 7:05 PM
- Where: Yankee Stadium, Bronx
- Where to watch: MLB Network
Blue Jays vs. Yankees – Game Betting Preview & Prediction
Moneyline: NY Yankees -137
Spread: NY Yankees -1.5 (+152)
Total: 8.5
New York Yankees Betting Preview
The Yankees (78-62) have finally found their stride after spending much of the summer clawing back in the AL East race. They’ve won 16 of their last 22 games and return home after a solid 5-2 road trip, including a series win in Houston capped by an 8-4 victory.
This current hot streak, highlighted by a 9-2 run in their last 11, gives New York momentum as they open a pivotal series against Toronto. Rookie Cam Schlittler (2-2, 2.61 ERA) will get the start, and he’s been impressive. Over his past six outings, he’s given up two runs or fewer, including just one total run across his last three starts (18 2/3 innings).
Schlittler faced Toronto once earlier this year, earning a no-decision after allowing two runs over five innings. His ability to keep games under control has been a huge boost for New York’s rotation. With the Yankees favored at -137 on the moneyline and the total set at 8.5 runs, the betting market respects their recent surge.
Toronto Blue Jays Betting Preview
The Blue Jays (81-59) have cooled since their dominant midsummer stretch but remain dangerous. They’ve gone just 18-17 over their last 35 games, though they’re coming into this series fresh off an offensive explosion in Cincinnati, where they racked up 25 runs and 30 hits in two games.
Toronto leans on Kevin Gausman (8-10, 3.75 ERA) to open this series. His season has been a roller coaster—though he’s pitched well recently, with a 3.24 ERA over his last four starts, he hasn’t earned a win during that span. Against the Yankees, Gausman has been inconsistent. He was shelled for six runs in New York back in April but bounced back with two quality outings at home in July.
With Toronto’s offense showing signs of life and Gausman capable of stabilizing, the Blue Jays won’t go down quietly. Still, they’ll need better execution on the mound to contain a Yankees team that’s been hot at the plate.
MLB Betting Outlook & Prediction
This series opener is all about form. The Yankees are playing their best baseball since May, while Toronto is coming off a short burst of offense but remains inconsistent. Schlittler’s recent dominance could be the X-factor, especially against a lineup he already handled once.
Score Prediction: Yankees 5, Blue Jays 3
Pick: NY Yankees (-137)
Total: Under 8.5 (+100)
- MLB Odds source: MyBookie Sportsbook
- Get real-time live scores & latest betting odds here!
